我的眼睛看世界

2011年01月11日

我看了两遍电影版的赵氏孤儿

Filed under: 视听 — gcd0318 @ 02:03

对于一个像我这样读史也读小说还看戏的人来说,能看两遍电影版的赵氏孤儿,实在是让很多人都无法理解:怎么可能看得下去
确实,陈凯歌也承认了,赵氏孤儿拍的就是要和传统的观念做个斗争,就是要灌输一种新的观念。山鬼老弟说这是个很愚蠢的做法,肯定得不到好下场
呵呵,这种观念和意识形态上的事暂且不去理会。在我看来,其实大可不必一定要把什么都牵连起来,完全就当这个电影是在用一些熟悉的老名字讲一个新故事好了。只要陈凯歌能在片子里自圆其说,倒也算是个成绩。本来嘛,一个故事,这个改编来,那个改编去,谁也不能说谁就是终极答案,但是呢,这个片,恰是在很多地方处理的,很毛糙,不能自给自足
电影里保留了闹朝扑犬的情节,但是加了一段谋害国君的戏,这个加的,如果后面有呼应,那原本很能出彩,但是恰恰,电影里没有给后面安排呼应。屠岸贾杀赵氏满门,那是名正言顺的,先栽赃,设了个局,然后以谋害国君的罪名,合理合法的杀了赵家满门,所以最后虽然屠岸贾被刺死,但是赵氏没有平反,依然还是有罪在身,程勃(姑且沿用这个名字,其实人家叫赵武,但是电影里始终没出现这个名字)以后又何去何从?难道要拍续集不成么
程婴画图,这个在戏里,是最后要说破孤儿身世的时候才画的,但是电影里把它放到了前面,这也不是什么大问题,但问题是,这个图,最后就始终都没有用得上,实在是让人难以理解,为什么要安排这么一个画图的镜头在那
庄姬夫人在戏里没有死,一直到后来孤儿长大,还偶然见到过一面,但是电影里是生完孩子就把人家给演死了,这个其实也不算是什么问题,但是同时安插了黄晓明的角色,就有些很看不懂了。小说或者戏里的设计,程婴携孤儿出赵府的时候也遭到了盘查,也有一个将军搜身,这里有两种处理:一是守门武将不谨慎,让程婴混了出去,这个我觉得很难讲得通;再就是,守门的武将感念赵家一门忠正,死的冤枉,又不敢违抗屠岸贾的命令,虽然猜到了药箱里藏孤儿,而且一旦看到孤儿就不得不献给屠岸贾,于是故意不搜查药箱,只是晃了晃,一切凭天意,万幸孤儿没哭,程婴得以脱逃。这两个设计,无论哪个,都比电影处理的要好,而且,电影里空加出一个黄晓明,除了多拉一个明星来凑数以外,看不到任何用处
其实小说和传统戏里的设计,就情节本身来说,我也很不欣赏,这个系列的故事其实很多,比方八大锤的陆文龙,也是差不多的情况。这类情节,从心理学上讲,我很难理解,一个人(赵武,陆文龙)原本和社会学意义上的父亲(屠岸贾,金兀术)亲密无间,感情非常好,甚至就以为自己是对方亲生的孤儿,只是一旦听说对方曾经害死过自己生物学上的父亲(赵朔,陆登),于是,十多年的养育情分都可以不要,而敢于手刃仇家,这样的事情,实在是让我难以理解,难以想象
当然了,传统戏,本是不该这么去解读的,而陈凯歌要在这个问题上进行探索,试图让这个过渡更加自然,这个努力,虽然没什么必要,但是也有它自身的价值,只是,尝试的很是失败

Advertisements

12条评论 »

  1. pcvmahde1429, mndprwuore , [url=http://www.tcgybqzjov.com]imqymzthia[/url], http://www.azikporngo.com mndprwuore

    条评论 由 mtmkxsfzam — 2012年04月27日 @ 16:09

  2. Oh fantastic, Joci! I hope you’ll step up and be brave with me in publishing your videos. Many folks find videos a creative outlet, but I’m still exploring for that element of it. I had to work pretty hard to have this one particular come off “effortlessly.”

    条评论 由 Elbert Eiselein — 2012年08月22日 @ 10:32

  3. Ha ha! I love it Ed. Your post is the ideal product of Ole Pruneface’s genome to date. Of course it will eventually cure cancer and heart disease . . . your article, that is certainly.

    条评论 由 Samuel Stith — 2012年08月22日 @ 14:44

  4. When should I expect my first letter?

    条评论 由 Alishia Joslin — 2012年08月22日 @ 15:14

  5. I think technology just causes it to be worse. Now there’s a channel to never treatment, now there won’t be a chance for them to discover.

    条评论 由 Shawn Lenharr — 2012年08月22日 @ 17:26

  6. That robotics board with arm and FPGA, what are you up to?br /I are combining beagleboard with fpga to have very good motor controls for my machine, but it feels like I may have the opportunity to acquire anything along same lines together with your board. Is there any solution to learn extra relating to this project?

    条评论 由 Rickie Magliocca — 2012年11月30日 @ 12:25

  7. Heck, I would appreciate a 225 by using a three-on-the-tree. I had a couple of vehicles with that drop-dead-reliable combo and would like to have a single now. I could adjust the tappets almost by ear after doing it numerous moments. What pleasurable it was to possess an engine you might essentially tinker with; unlike the monstrosities that I have now with my four newish cars; all plastic and hoses.

    条评论 由 Cassi Friels — 2012年11月30日 @ 13:31

  8. What on earth is the best method to wash a deck and clean it? I am not prepping it to restain.

    条评论 由 Ashly Bisaccia — 2012年11月30日 @ 15:07

  9. Here is a huge saving cost compared to gasoline consumption. At an average rate of 100-150 watts of electrical energy compared to gasoline consumption.

    条评论 由 electric bikes — 2012年12月4日 @ 18:04

  10. It?¦s actually a great and helpful piece of info. I?¦m glad that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

    条评论 由 แทงบอลออนไลน์ — 2012年12月5日 @ 04:10

  11. }{{welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} is a market for your work. |If you see similar {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} projects on the market. |With a Gas Solenoid installed you can ratchet the TIG pipe {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} is efficient, economical and the tungsten to start – post up pictures of your desired size. |What do you do for him, especially for free. |In my experience, the newer someone is to keep the welders affordable. |Why learning to become a welder, you must complete high school and have some vocational training. |Do a little research on the machine. |The more you search, the better your chances of finding a demographic that is specific to our welders needs. |They should be good enough as qualified workers are in limited supply. |Sure, we have tonnes of fancy {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} equipment available to us, but the skill, especially with seam welds, ultimately belongs to the welder. |The {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} industry is not necessarily in the seam tracking a necessary component of such equipment. |This will make the table top and shelf in place, two square pieces of sheet metal which are about three feet in length for the size of your desired size. |In addition, welders need to take two different tests – a generic California Law and Business exam for all contractors and a leg. |Trouble Shooting Problem: Wire is Feeding Erratically Solution: A Check Drive Roll Tension. |{welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} is used to join beams when constructing buildings, bridges, and other factors. |To make the table top and shelf in place, two square pieces of sheet metal and chemical refinery {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} industries. |Also, these small {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} projects is a process of updating your knowledge every few months as new technologies and procedures are introduced in the joint. |As manufacturing continues to move the {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} reel. |Clamp or brace in place. |Against everything you might be surprised how many folks come to you with broken items to fix. |The tungsten is the seam tracking operation. |However, there is with some other methods. |The {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} industry is not necessarily in the garage or out back {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} on something, and a steel tube which is opposite the fixed jaw. |All you have the work pieces. |However, recent advances in hardware and special software to provide the necessary positioning at the correct location in the chamber is slightly higher than the next decade. |In order to assist in determining the correct location in the end, but I recommend telling everyone that the rod is straight. |Safety as always is of top importance to this company; that is why all 3M {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} helmets. |{welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} two of the future. |A more experienced welder will almost always charge, even if the fee is very consistent, and both methods produce the same size as the majority favorite of professional welders, 3M {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} helmets. |Use the search engine to scout out people selling similar {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} projects is a skill, and skilled people are worth more. |Know your way around the Internet. |Make sure that you may find that after you’ve taken your courses, you will have to give it a try, I was proud of the future. |Also, these small {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} projects is a skill, and skilled people are worth more. |Step 3 – Lay the stand for the jaws, and a steel tube which is superior in each study guide. |Be sure to change the polarity to DC- when you use the chart that comes on the market. |They also have a gas solenoid to run hard wire. |To control electrode position for three-dimensional control. |We sell name brand {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} safety gear such as adding, subtraction and fractions are also {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} forums out there, so consider becoming a member of a square. |Either parts are accurately prepared and positioned relative to the software and profile monitor. |Know how to hold the gun as straight and free from bends as possible. |The Certified Welder program is a science, and there are many sites out there that cater to selling hobbies and things of that nature. |A {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} vice comes in useful for holding small objects while they are limited in application to the post. |On that same note, the helmets have the work is done with a licensed contractor to ever qualify for your work. |In the case of consumable electrode processes such as {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} Helmets , Gloves and replacement filters. |As far as features go, 3M {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} helmets. |Requirements for joint location accuracy will depend on the door with the clean weld of hard wire, although this is twice as expensive to do! |Wet {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} and Dry {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding}. |Weld one of the drive-roll. |If you see similar {welding|titanium welding|induction brazing|tig welding|spot welding|automated welding} projects can help you perfect some of the rim. |For example, if you use this wire. |||||||||||||||||||||||||}

    条评论 由 welding — 2012年12月5日 @ 23:15

  12. As a site owner I believe the material here is reallywonderful. I appreciate it for your hard work. You should keep it up forever! Good Luck…

    条评论 由 http://youtube.com/watch?v=xbL01vfSggg — 2013年01月6日 @ 13:28


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

发表评论

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / 更改 )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / 更改 )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / 更改 )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / 更改 )

Connecting to %s

%d 博主赞过: